Hybrid's Alter Economics for Carmakers and Owners

Hybrid-drive technology is impacting auto manufacturing, selling, owning and repairing automoibles.

Published: 05-Jan-2006

lass=textBodyBlack>With gasoline prices stuck well above $2 a gallon, and sales of gas-guzzling sport utility vehicles declining, this would seem to be prime time for fuel-efficient hybrids. Dealers report that traffic to showrooms has picked up, and manufacturers are prepping more models to meet demand. And as hybrids begin moving into the mainstream, they are changing the way cars are designed, sold, made and repaired.

Although U.S. sales of hybrid vehicles roughly doubled in 2005, they still make up a tiny fraction of new car sales. From less than 10,000 sold in 2000, hybrid sales are estimated to have broken 200,000 in 2005, according to HybridCrs.com, but that is only about 1 percent of the roughly 17 million cars and light trucks sold overall.

One big reason, say analysts, is the added cost of a hybrid compared to a conventional gasoline-powered vehicle. That premium varies but can run as much as $7,000. So far, hybrid buyers tend to come from two groups: “early adopters” looking for the latest technology and environmentalists, who may care more about saving the planet than saving money.

"Neither of these are particularly sensitive to the economics. They have other reasons why they're buying this," said David Cole, chairman of the Center for Automotive Research. "There’s a question as to how large those groups are, but once you get to more mainstream buying groups, then economics really begins to take over as a primary factor in that decision."

The math goes something like this: If you drive a conventional gas-powered car that gets 20 miles per gallon for 100,000 miles, you’ll burn through 5,000 gallons of gas. If you buy a hybrid that gets 33 miles per gallon, you’ll save roughly 2,000 gallons over that same 100,000 miles. At $2.50 a gallon, that will save you $5,000. (To sweeten the deal, Congress this year gave hybrid buyers a tax credit of about $2,000 depending on the model.)

So for new car buyers trying to decide whether they will save money on a hybrid, the answer depends heavily on where gasoline prices are headed, according to Corey Shaker, CEO of Hometown Auto Retailers, a publicly held chain of auto dealerships in the Northeast.

"If gas is $4.50 a gallon, (the answer is) yes," he said. "If gas is $1.65 a gallon, no. You can buy a lot of gas for $3,000."

And the hybrid premium is turning out to be bigger than the difference in sticker prices. Because production of hybrids is still limited and demand is strong, dealers are typically getting the full sticker price for a hybrid — even as they heavily discount most conventional models.

The hybrid’s higher sticker price may come down a bit as manufacturing ramps up. But it will probably always be part of the purchase equation, according to Cole.

"There are a lot of additional parts (in a hybrid) because you have parallel power systems, electrical and mechanical," he said. "So even over the long term, with economies of scale, you’re still dealing with several thousands dollars of inherent cost difference."

While consumers make up their minds, automakers are hedging their bets by producing hybrid versions of conventional models, essentially offering hybrid drive trains as just another option. (One exception is the Toyota Prius, the best-selling hybrid to date, which is available only as a hybrid. But Toyota's future hybrids will also be available as conventional gas-powered models.)

Carmakers are also pursuing different engineering strategies.

Toyota’s full-hybrid "synergy drive" relies on large electric motors that provide full power at low speeds, reserving the gas-powered engine for passing and cruising at higher speeds. Ford is using a similar technology. GM’s "mild" hybrid technology, due next year, , uses smaller electric motors that are built into the transmission. GM’s "two mode" approach doesn’t rely as heavily on the electric motors, but GM says it will be cheaper to produce. The techology is also being adopted by DaimlerChrysler and BMW. Honda is also using a mild hybrid technology.

"Our desire is to get the most economy that we can out of a given vehicle with the smallest motors and smallest battery pack that we can,"  said Larry Nitz, executive director of GM’s hybrid powertrain program.

Critics of GM’s strategy say the company hasn’t moved as quickly, and their hybrid designs don’t use the technology as aggressively, as Japanese rival Toyota.

"What GM is talking about in my book are not hybrids," said David Healy, an auto analyst with Burnham Securities. "These are trucks with humongous starter motors."

The idea behind hybrids has been around for years. The main reason for combining the two power systems is that electric motors operate most efficiently at low speeds and gasoline engines operate most efficiently at high speeds. Making the two work together smoothly and efficiently just wasn’t possible without the latest generation of cheap, powerful microprocessors, according to Nitz.

For automakers, the main challenge has been to design and engineer drive trains with two separate power sources — without adding big costs. One big hurdle has been the relatively slow pace of improvement in battery technology. Advances in lithium ion power storage may some day bring smaller lighter batteries. But for now hybrids rely on large, heavy nickel metal hydride technology, which adds significant cost and weight to each vehicle.

"In the world of nickel metal hydride, the supply base is very immature, the choice of suppliers is very limited and the economies of scale are very limited," said Nitz.

With American carmakers slashing jobs and looking for ways to cut costs, designers are also looking for ways to produce more cars with fewer workers. That may be tough to do with drivetrains that include the added parts needed to provide two separate power systems.

And while any new technology brings the prospect of further job cutbacks, expanding hybrid production should be good news for workers who are worried about their jobs, according to Harley Shaiken, a professor at the University of California in Berkeley who specializes in labor and the global economy.

"It is potentially very good news for autoworkers if the U.S. firms get with the program," he said. "The danger isn’t hybrid technology. The danger is that the Big Three are slow to adopt and to adapt to where the markets going."

For hybrid owners, it's too soon to know how the cost of upkeep and repairs will compare to conventional cars and light trucks. So far the track record for most hybrid owners has been good. But earlier this year, Toyota recalled 160,000 Prius hybrids because of problems with their engines stopping. A glitch in the computer programming controlling the electronic units was believed to be behind the problem.

The long-term reliability of any new technology is difficult to predict. To increase the turnaround time from design to production, automakers have stepped up what is known as accelerated testing of new parts and technologies, running them under stressful conditions to simulate their expected lifespan and identify problems. But they are finding that this virtual testing can only go so far, according to Cole.

"It might be just the age of a wiring insulator, where the polymer changes over a period of time," he said. "You can do all sort of sorts of accelerated testing, but when five years goes by you’ve got a problem that you never saw in that accelerated testing. That’s an issue that every one of the manufacturers has run into."

So far, with so few hybrids on the road, there are very few showing up in repair shops. Dealers and independent service centers say their technicians are already trained to take care of the increasingly complex technology in conventional cars and light trucks. So the introduction of hybrids doesn’t represent a radical change. It does, however, highlight a growing shortage of trained workers who can tackle the latest advances in auto repair, said Dennis DeCota, executive director of the California Service Station and Automotive Repair Association.

"Our basic problem has been getting sufficient training with the cutbacks on the junior college and state college levels in automotive repair programs," he said. "Career technical education has taken a back seat in many districts, and it’s created a huge shortfall of qualified technicians. We’re running into a real problem."

And there is a big battle brewing over so-called "after market" parts. As electronics become more deeply embedded, automakers are holding back the software needed to make aftermarket parts and diagnostic tools, according repair shop owners. So the parts industry is looking for help from Congress with the proposed Right to Repair Act, which would force automakers to provide more information to after-market companies that make spare parts.

"Even with the non-hybrids, the after-market parts companies are getting squeezed out of making after market parts — especially the electronic stuff," said Ken Bach, owner of Bach Auto in Smithton, Penn. "So with these hybrids, I see a definite problem: that if you need something, you’re only going to be able to get it from the dealer or the manufacturer."

Bach says without competition from after-market parts makers, the cost of hybrid replacement parts will remain high.

"Once a part becomes available in the after market, you watch how much it decreases in price at the dealer level," he said. "If there isn’t an after-market fender available, the fender could be $500. he said. The minute the after market fender becomes available, it’ll drop to $300.”

<< PREVIOUSNEXT >>
RELATED NEWS ITEMS

Playing catch-up a decade late, the world's auto giants now find that they have to lease or buy technology from Toyota.

Spc. Jeffrey Hamme and Staff Sgt. Michelangelo Merksamer of HHC, 1/506th Infantry, point out features of the Hybrid Electric Humvee at the AUSA Annual Meeting earlier this month. The two Soldiers participated in a Military Utility Assessment of the prototype vehicle last month at Fort Campbell, Ky.

Ford's 'Hybrid Patrol,' a 10-city initiative this fall that aims to show hybrid drivers how to drive for best fuel economy. EV World photo of Bill and Lisa Hammond on way to first Ford Patrol event in Detroit during stop-over in Omaha.

READER COMMENTS

blog comments powered by Disqus